New quantitative data suggests that 30% of the surgeries performed for non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients in a community-wide clinical study were deemed unnecessary. Additionally, positron emission tomography (PET) was found to reduce unnecessary surgeries by 50%.
PET imaging prior to surgery helps stage a patient’s disease by providing functional images of tumors throughout the body, especially areas where cancer has spread, otherwise known as metastasis. Few studies have been able to pin down exactly what impact preoperative PET has on clinical decision-making and resulting treatment.
Preliminary review of the data from this long-term, observational study of an entire community of veterans was inconclusive about the utility of PET. Notably, after a more thorough statistical analysis accounting for selection bias and other confounding factors, the researchers were able to conclude that PET imaging eliminated approximately half of unnecessary surgeries.
“It has become standard of care for lung cancer patients to receive preoperative PET imaging,” said lead author Steven Zeliadt, PhD. The study, published in the Journal of Nuclear Medicine (2014; doi:10.2967/jnumed.113.124230), was conducted at Veterans Affairs Puget Sound Health Care System in Seattle, Washington. “The prevailing evidence reinforces the general understanding within the medical community that PET is very useful for identifying occult metastasis and that it helps get the right people to surgery while avoiding unnecessary surgeries for those who would not benefit.”
For this study, researchers reviewed patients with newly diagnosed NSCLC who received preoperative PET to assess the real-life effectiveness of PET as a preventive measure against unnecessarily invasive treatment across a community of patients. A total of 2,977 veterans who underwent PET during disease staging from 1997 to 2009 were included in the study. Of these, 976 patients underwent surgery to resect their lung cancer. During surgery or within 12 months of surgery, 30% of these patients were found to have advanced-stage metastatic disease, indicating an unnecessary surgery.
Interestingly, the use of PET increased during the study period from 9% to 91%. Conventional multivariate analyses was followed by instrumental variable analyses to account for unobserved anomalies, such as when patients did not undergo PET when it would have been clinically recommended to do so. This new data has the potential to change policy and recommendations regarding the use of oncologic PET for more accurate tumor staging.
“We will likely build more quality measures around this research so that preoperative PET is more strongly recommended to improve the management of care for these patients,” added Zeliadt.