Tube feeding is the better option for malnourished pediatric cancer patients
Approximately 60% of pediatric cancer patients experience malnourishment during treatment. Patients and families have a choice between tube feeding and IV nutrition supplementation. A new study shows families' perceptions, especially of the discomfort of tube feeding, leads to choosing IV supplementation over tube feeding. This is despite the fact that tube feeding is usually the better choice because it is associated with better gut function and lower rates of infection.
"Despite the benefits of tube feeding, we found a strong preference among families and older pediatric patients for IV feeding," said the study's senior author Kitty Montgomery, MS, RN, PCNS-BC, CPHON, of Children's Hospital Colorado, a clinical care partner of the University of Colorado Cancer Center. Montgomery and colleagues conducted the study while at the Children's Hospital Wisconsin in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
The study surveyed 49 parents and older pediatric cancer patients. Of 14 patients, all reported preferring IV feeding over tube feeding. Their responses included, “I already had a port in for chemo, so we used that for TPN,” and, “Tube feeding sounds disgusting and uncomfortable.”
“When nutrition support is needed, most health care teams suggest tube feeding first. Only, we tend to find resistance to the idea from parents or patients,” Montgomery said, describing the research that was reported in the Journal of Pediatric Oncology Nursing (2013; doi:10.1177/1043454212471726). “This study shows us the reasons for those objections and we hope will help us learn to break down those barriers to the best method of support.”
Parents of pediatric cancer patients were much more evenly split between preference for tube feeding (41%) and IV feeding (59%), with the parents who preferred tube feeding frequently citing information about the procedure given by the treatment team as the reason for their choice. For example, one parent said, "Tube feeding is helpful in giving meds and not as hard on the liver and keeps the digestive system working properly." Another parent who preferred tube feeding said they, "chose tube feedings because it helped to keep digestive system active, making it easier to adjust back to food."
"This helps us tailor our message," says Montgomery. "We see now that the biggest barrier to tube feeding is perceived discomfort, so health care professionals may have better success with patients and parents by addressing that issue. What we need to do now is learn to translate these findings into action."
This article was updated on February 22, 2013.